Case study · saas · revenue

Monthly or yearly? How billing toggles shape what SaaS buyers choose

An interactive pattern case study: how annual vs monthly billing toggles frame price, which defaults are honest, and how to measure the effect on revenue, cash and churn.

Pattern analysis

Slide 1 of 10

The pattern: one toggle, two prices, many framings

Most SaaS pricing pages offer monthly or annual billing, with a discount for paying yearly. The toggle looks small, but it decides three things: which option is pre-selected, how the price is expressed, and how the saving is described.

Phil uses a composite product, Formsmith, an online form builder.

Slide 2 of 10

WXM 1 · Wonder (Look)

Wonder: the same price, framed four ways

All four describe the same plan: €12 monthly, or €120 a year if paid annually.

  1. €10/month, billed annually
  2. €120/year
  3. Save €24 with annual billing
  4. 2 months free with annual billing
  5. Describing the same facts differently changes judgments; attribute framing effects are among the most consistent. [Source](#src-levin-1998-framing)

Slide 3 of 10

WXM 1 · Wonder (Look)

Wonder: a common version

Annual pre-selected, monthly price only shown after switching, total charge in small print.

Control (A)
Pricing card, a common pattern (composite) Original wireframe, not a screenshot.
  1. Monthly hidden. Visitors only see the monthly price if they find and flip the toggle.
  2. Charge in small print. The amount that will actually be charged is the least visible number.

Slide 4 of 10

WXM 1 · Wonder (Look)

Wonder: what goes wrong

Typical signals behind this pattern:

  1. Support tickets and refund requests: "I thought I was paying €10, not €120."
  2. Chargebacks and early cancellations from annual buyers.
  3. Defaults strongly shape choices, which is why they deserve care. [Source](#src-jachimowicz-2019-defaults)

Slide 5 of 10

WXM 2 · Architect (Plan)

Architect: an honest toggle

Because refund requests and tickets show buyers surprised by the annual charge, we believe showing both prices side by side (monthly price and annual total with the saving) with annual pre-selected will keep revenue per visitor and reduce refunds, because buyers choose annual knowingly.

Your turn: Which display is honest with annual pre-selected?
Show Phil’s answer

Annual: €120/year (€10/month, save €24) · Monthly: €12/month, both clearly visible. Both options and the real charge are clear. The buyer can still be nudged by the default and the saving, but nobody is surprised.

Slide 6 of 10

WXM 2 · Architect (Plan)

Architect: how does it score on PXL?

Above the fold on a high-intent page, noticeable, backed by support tickets and refund data, quick to build. It changes display rather than adding or removing an element.

PXL score: 10 / 14

PXL criteria breakdown
Is the change above the fold?Yes1
Is it noticeable within 5 seconds?Yes2
Does it add or remove an element?No0
Is it designed to increase user motivation?Yes1
Does it run on high-traffic page(s)?Yes1
Does it address an issue found in user testing?No0
Does it address an issue found in qualitative feedback (surveys, polls, interviews)?Yes1
Does it address insights found in digital analytics?Yes1
Is it supported by mouse-tracking heatmaps or eye tracking?No0
Ease of implementationUnder 4 hours3

PXL by CXL. A high score ranks an idea; it does not predict a win.

Slide 7 of 10

WXM 3 · Validate (Test)

Validate: the variation

Two clear options instead of a hidden toggle, each showing what will be charged.

Control (A)
A: toggle, monthly hidden Original wireframe, not a screenshot.
Variation (B)
B: both options, real charges visible Original wireframe, not a screenshot.
  1. No surprise. The button says what will be charged.

Slide 8 of 10

WXM 3 · Validate (Test)

Validate: the test plan, written before launch

Fixed in advance:

  1. Primary metric: revenue per visitor over 90 days (annual payments counted over time, not all at once).
  2. Guardrails: refunds, chargebacks, support tickets about billing.
  3. Secondary: annual share of new subscriptions, monthly-plan retention at 90 days.
  4. Decision rule: ship if 90-day revenue holds or improves and refunds fall.

Phil says: Annual plans bring cash forward. Don't let a big first-day number hide refunds that come back next week.

Slide 9 of 10

WXM 4 · Expand (Grow)

Expand: what the pattern usually leads to

This is a pattern, not a report of one company's test. Typical next steps:

  1. Test the saving's framing ('save €24' vs '2 months free') with the honest layout in place.
  2. Send a reminder before annual renewal. It reduces angry renewals and builds trust.
  3. Look at which customers choose monthly and whether they upgrade later.

Slide 10 of 10

Your turn

Look at your pricing page as a new visitor. Can you see what you'll be charged today without flipping anything? Read the framing effect and the default effect.

What this pattern teaches

  • Wonder compared four framings of the same price.
  • Architect kept the default but made both options and the real charge visible.
  • Validate measured revenue over 90 days and refunds, not first-day cash.
  • Expand extended honesty to renewal reminders.

Formsmith is a composite product used to illustrate a common pattern.

Frequently asked questions

Should a SaaS pricing page default to annual or monthly billing?

Either can be honest. If annual is the default, show the monthly option and its price equally clearly, show the full annual amount that will be charged, and make switching easy. Test the default on revenue per visitor and retention.

Is this based on a real company?

No. It describes a pattern seen across many SaaS pricing pages, illustrated with a composite product. It doesn't attribute results to any company.

Sources (4)

  1. All Frames Are Not Created Equal: A Typology and Critical Analysis of Framing Effects. Levin, Schneider and Gaeth, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 76(2), 1998. Accessed 14 November 2026.
  2. When and why defaults influence decisions: a meta-analysis of default effects. Jachimowicz, Duncan, Weber and Johnson, Behavioural Public Policy 3(2), 2019. Accessed 14 November 2026.
  3. WXM: the Wave Experimentation Model. Wavesy. Accessed 4 November 2026.
  4. PXL: A Better Way to Prioritize Your A/B Tests. CXL. Accessed 4 November 2026.

Learn the principles behind this case

Search lessons, guides, case studies and templates. Press Esc to close.